Pink Oak vs. White Oak

Synopsis: Delve into the main points of oak wooden, which boasts greater than 500 completely different species the world over. For woodworking functions, pink oak and white oak are the principle classes, and there are vital variations between them. Pink oak is inexpensive, has a hotter tone and coarser grain, and is commonly used for flooring and cabinetry. White oak is pricier, has distinguished ray fleck, darkens effectively with fuming, and is commonly used for tremendous furnishings, notably Arts and Crafts. There are extra delicate variations, too, explored within the article.

---

Civilization wouldn’t be the place it’s with out oak timber. Ships wouldn’t have been as sturdy or seaworthy, nor buildings and bridges as giant and sturdy, so commerce, journey, and business wouldn’t have thrived as they did. Wine and bourbon definitely wouldn’t be as tasty. And woodworkers wouldn’t have certainly one of their strongest and most considerable supplies for furnishings.

There are greater than 500 species of oak on the earth, with roughly 90 in North America alone. A dozen or so are bought commercially. These fall into two distinct classes, white and pink. The variations between the 2 teams are far more vital than the minor variations inside them.

Wooden bought as “white oak” in North America ranges from precise white oak (Quercus alba) to chinkapin (Quercus muehlenbergii), swamp white oak (Quercus bicolor), and bur oak (Quercus macrocarpa). Europeans purchase and use American white oak however have their very own varieties as effectively. English oak (Quercus robur) and sessile oak (Quercus patraea) are two white oaks generally used throughout the pond.

Aside from the truth that bur oak has barely darker heartwood, it’s very laborious to inform the distinction between these white-oak species.

White oak Like “pink oak,” “white oak” is an umbrella time period for a wide range of species with related look and efficiency. These embody white oak, chinkapin, swamp white oak, and bur oak. In Europe, English oak and sessile oak are sometimes used. White oak leaves have rounded suggestions. Most-common species: White oak Latin title: Quercus alba Particular gravity (12% MC): .75 Common weight (dry): 47 lb./cubic foot Janka hardness: 1350 lb. Radial shrinkage: 5.6% Tangential shrinkage: 10.5%

Wooden bought as “pink oak” in North America is often Northern pink oak (Quercus rubra) or black oak (Quercus velutina). However pin oak (Quercus palustris), Shumard oak (Quercus shumardii), and Southern pink oak (Quercus falcata) are additionally within the combine.

Pink oak A wide range of species are bought as “pink oak” in North America, with very related look, weight, power, and workability. The commonest are Northern pink oak and black oak. Others embody pin oak, Shumard oak, and Southern pink oak. Pink oak leaves have pointed or bristled suggestions. Most-common species: Northern pink oak Latin title: Quercus rubra Particular gravity (12% MC): .7 Common weight (dry): 43.8 lb./cubic foot Janka hardness: 1220 lb. Radial shrinkage: 4% Tangential shrinkage: 8.6%

Sawmills take logs from these species, noticed them into boards, and label them white or pink oak. At that time, it’s almost unimaginable to inform their species with out a DNA check. And for woodworkers, it’s not necessary, as look, weight, power, and workability are comparatively constant inside every class.

What issues, then, is tips on how to inform pink oak from white, and understanding the distinctive qualities of every.

White oak has a whole lot of benefits

Whereas pink and white oak are equally sturdy, and each work properly with hand and energy instruments, there are many necessary variations between the 2.

Pink oak is extra broadly out there than white, bought all over the place from residence facilities to {hardware} shops. Species bought as white oak, then again, can be found principally from hardwood retailers and small sawmills, the place they are often twice as expensive as pink oak, principally as a result of the logs are more durable to come back by.

Other than value and availability, a lot of the variations between the categories are associated to the wooden’s look. Pink oak often has a reddish solid and infrequently runs just a little darker than white, although not all the time. In pink oak the colour of the heartwood—the bigger, inside portion of the log that receives essentially the most use—varies from pale reddish brown to mild tan, whereas white oak’s heartwood runs from pale or greenish tan to grayish brown. The grain of the 2 woods can be very completely different. Pink oak has a better variety of giant pores, making its grain look coarser and its grain traces extra distinguished.

For extra images and data, click on on the “view PDF” button under:

Drawings: John Tetreault

From Fantastic Woodworking #306

 

 

View PDF